Alert Electrical Limited

Fire Alarm Systems - Smoke Alarms Product Comparison Guide

Alarm Sensing Technologies

SMOKE ALARMS
There are two types of sensor for detecting smoke, neither one is better than the other, both detect smoke but are sensitive to different types of fire and smoke:

IONISATION TECHNOLOGY
Ionisation technology is generally more sensitive than photoelectric technology at detecting small particles, which tend
to be produced in greater amounts by flaming fires, which consume combustible materials rapidly and spread quickly.
Sources of these fires may include paper burning in a wastebasket, or grease fires.

PHOTOELECTRIC TECHNOLOGY

Photoelectric technology is generally more sensitive than ionisation technology at detecting large particles, which tend to
be produced in greater amounts by smouldering fires, which may smoulder for hours before bursting into flame. Sources
of these fires may include cigarettes burning in bedding or furniture.

HEAT ALARMS
BRK heat alarms should form part of any fire protection installation. They are designed for areas where dust, fumes and
benign smoke may trigger frequent nuisance alarms in conventional ionisation and photoelectric smoke alarms. Ideal for
lofts, garages & kitchens, heat alarms are now required within the latest Building Regulations.
The heat alarms use advanced thermistor sensor technology, the most advanced and reliable method of heat detection.
Using thermistors, the varying electrical resistance of a semi-conductor is used to detect increases in temperature.
The detectors work on a fixed point principle, where the alarm activates when the temperature reaches the preset range of
54ºC to 70ºC.

CARBON MONOXIDE ALARMS
Using the latest Electrochemical sensing technology BRK carbon monoxide alarms are designed for domestic use.
Electrochemical alarms work by converting the carbon monoxide electrochemically to carbon dioxide, which generates an
electrical current that is taken as a measure of the gas concentration. Electrochemical alarms can be both mains and battery
powered and typically have a lifespan of five years. Photoelectric technology has been recommended for many years as the ideal compliment to ionisation technology, Fire Brigade advice is to use both photoelectric and ionisation technology for maximum protection. There are growing restrictions across Europe in alarms using Ionisation sensors. Therefore the demand for Photoelectric sensors is increasing.

Manufacturer Comparison 

Product

DICON

AICO

KIDDE

FIREX

SENSO

SECTOR

NEW

WF

DETA

ELECT

Ionisation    Range

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Mains + 9V Back Up

670 MBX

 EI141

ISF23 9HI

4870

3820

SD3+

3631

6638

1111

 5060

 Mains Only

670 M

 EI150 / EI140

123i

4850

3820L

SD5

3632

6639

 

 5050

 Mains+Recharg. Capacitor Back Up

670 MC

 

 

 

 

SD4

 

 

 

 5080

 Mains+Recharg.

Lithium Back Up

670 MRL

 151/161

ISF23/ 9HIR

4881

3820LR

SD14RC

 

 

 

 5070

 Battery Only

M300

 100B

0914UKC

4800

3120

SD1

3630

6637

1101

 5040

 Battery -10 Year Lithium

SA900

 

 

 

3120FC

 

 

 

1103

 

Base for Mains Units

CB232

 157/127

SMK23

4890

PAT

SM1

3633

6760

1110

 5045

Photoelectric Range 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Mains + 9V Back Up

650 MBX

 146

2SF23/9HI

4973

5820

 

 

 

1113

 

 Mains Only

650 M

 

155/145

223i

4953

5820L

SD13

 

 

 

 5051

 Mains + Recharg Capacitor Back Up

650 MC

 

 

 

 

SD6

 

 

 

 5081

 Mains + Recharg Lithium back Up

650 MRL

   156TLH /166RC 

2SF23/9HIR

4985

5820LR

SD15RC

 

 

 

 5071

 Mains + Alkaline Batt. Back Up

7010BE

See 650mbx

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Mains + Lithium Batt. Back Up

7010LBE

See 650mbx10

 

4973L

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Battery + Long Life Lithium (10 y)

Sa410LLi

 

 

 

5120

 

 

 

 

 

 Heat Range

Mains+ 9V  Back Up

680 MBX

 144

3SF23/9HI

4899

7820

 

 

4303

1115

 

 Mains Only

680 M

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Mains +Recharg.Capacitor Back Up

680 MC

 

 

 

7820L

 

 

 

 

 

 Mains + Recharg.Lithium Back Up

680MRL

154TL

/164RC

3SF23/9HIR

4892

7820LR

 

 

 

 

 

             

 Product

 

DICON

 

AICO

 

KIDDE

 

FIREX

 

SENSO

 

SECTOR

 

NEW

 

WF

 

DETA

 

 ELECT

Wireless Bases

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Radio Frequency Bases

CB600RF

 168RC

 

 

PATWFL

 

 

 

 

 

 Carbon Monoxide

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Battery Only

CO4000EN

 205ENA

900-0259

 

4CB

SCO850B

3621N

7543

1123

5041

Mains Powered with Interlink

CO850MI 

 225EN

 

 

 

SCO850MI

3620N

4305

1121

5091

Mains Powered with 9V Alkaline Batt.Back Up

CO850mbxi

 

900-0211UK

 

 

 

3624

4306

 

5090

Mains Powered with Tamper-proof Rechargeable Lithium cells

CO850mrli

 261ENRC

423/9hir

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Pattresses

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Surface Bases

CB232

 157/127

SMK23

4890

PAT

SM1

3633

6760

1110

5045

Relay Bases

CB300

 128R

SMK23R

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


alert_twitter

alert_follow

Price Match Promise
Worldwide Delivery

Ask a question

Next Day Delivery

All enquiries please contact via live chat 9am - 4pm Monday to Friday support@support.alertelectrical.com please include your order number (Starts W201..)

© Copyright 2012 Alert Electrical Limited. Unit 2/3 Clarendon Court | Manners Industrial Estate | Ilkeston | Derbyshire | DE7 8EFTop